1949510165525294
top of page

What's the Best Type of Marriage Counseling? A Guide to Choosing the Right Approach

Writer: Alexis Honeycutt, LMHC, Certified Gottman Therapist
Alexis Honeycutt, LMHC, Certified Gottman Therapist
6 days ago
8 min read

When a couple decides to pursue marriage counseling, one of the first questions they may encounter is one they probably weren't expecting.


What kind of marriage counseling should we choose?


A quick search reveals several approaches, each with its own terminology, theories, and claims about how relationships improve. There is the Gottman Method, Emotionally Focused Therapy, Behavioral Couples Therapy, and other established approaches.


For someone who simply wants to stop having the same painful argument with their spouse, the number of options can become overwhelming.


Most couples aren't looking for a particular therapeutic theory. They want to understand why their relationship isn't working the way they want it to, what can be done about it, and whether the professional they choose can actually help.


Those are reasonable questions.


The answer is not that one method is universally best for every marriage. The more useful question is which approach, delivered by which therapist, offers the right kind of help for your relationship.


What Makes One Type of Marriage Counseling Different From Another?


Couples therapy is not a single standardized treatment.


Different approaches are built around different explanations of how relationship problems develop and what helps couples change them.


Some focus heavily on identifying patterns of communication and teaching specific relationship skills. Others concentrate on emotional responses, attachment needs, and the ways partners react to one another when they feel threatened or disconnected.


Still others emphasize behavior change, acceptance, or the interaction between individual differences and recurring relationship problems.


These approaches are not necessarily opposites.


A therapist helping couples improve communication cannot ignore emotions. A therapist working with emotional attachment cannot ignore behavior. Most relationship difficulties involve both.


The differences lie in how the therapist understands the problem, organizes treatment, and chooses interventions.


Understanding those distinctions can make it easier to find a therapist whose training and approach align with what your relationship needs.


The Gottman Method: Assessment, Research, and Practical Relationship Skills


The Gottman Method is an established approach to couples therapy developed by Drs. John and Julie Gottman.


It draws on decades of research into couple interactions, conflict, friendship, emotional connection, and relationship stability.


One of its defining characteristics is the emphasis on assessment before developing a treatment plan.


Rather than assuming that the most recent argument represents the whole problem, a Gottman Method therapist evaluates the relationship's strengths, areas of difficulty, and recurring patterns.


The assessment may include conversations with the couple together, individual interviews with each partner, and structured questionnaires.


This information helps the therapist identify where interventions may be most useful.


Treatment often addresses several interconnected areas of the relationship: strengthening friendship and emotional connection, managing conflict more effectively, repairing past hurts, and developing a stronger sense of shared meaning.


The approach also gives couples practical tools they can use beyond their appointments.


For example, when a couple repeatedly argues about an unresolved issue, therapy may examine not only the subject of the disagreement but also how the conversation begins, how each partner responds, and what happens when emotions escalate.


The goal is not simply to help the couple reach agreement on every issue.


Some relationship differences cannot be permanently eliminated. Learning how to discuss those differences without repeatedly damaging the relationship can be an important part of treatment.


The Gottman Method may particularly appeal to couples who appreciate a thorough assessment, a clear therapeutic structure, and specific interventions supported by relationship research.



Emotionally Focused Therapy: Understanding the Emotional Patterns Beneath Conflict


Emotionally Focused Therapy, commonly called EFT, is another established approach to couples treatment.


Developed by Dr. Sue Johnson and colleagues, EFT is grounded in attachment theory and focuses on the emotional bonds between partners.


It examines how couples become caught in patterns that leave both people feeling increasingly disconnected.


Consider a familiar situation.


One partner wants reassurance and begins asking questions. The other experiences those questions as criticism and withdraws. The withdrawal increases the first partner's anxiety, leading to more questions and greater pressure.


Both partners may feel misunderstood, even though both are responding to their own experiences of emotional disconnection.


EFT helps couples recognize these interaction patterns and understand the underlying emotions and attachment needs contributing to them.


Rather than treating the visible argument as the entire problem, the therapist helps the couple explore what each partner is experiencing underneath their defensive or withdrawn responses.


The objective is to create different emotional interactions and strengthen the couple's sense of connection and security.


EFT has a substantial research literature supporting its use with distressed couples.


It may appeal to couples who want to better understand the emotional experiences that repeatedly influence their interactions.


Importantly, EFT is not simply about expressing feelings, just as the Gottman Method is not simply about learning communication techniques. Both are comprehensive clinical approaches, and both address emotion and interaction.


Their differences concern how they conceptualize change and organize the therapeutic process.


Behavioral Couples Therapy: Changing the Patterns That Keep Repeating


Behavioral approaches represent another important area of couples therapy.


These include traditional Behavioral Couples Therapy, cognitive-behavioral approaches, and Integrative Behavioral Couple Therapy, often abbreviated IBCT.


These models examine the behaviors, expectations, and interactions that contribute to relationship distress.


A couple may have developed habits that reinforce the very problems they want to solve.


Perhaps attempts at discussing finances consistently end in criticism and withdrawal. Perhaps one partner's efforts to help are interpreted as interference. Over time, even ordinary interactions begin producing frustration.


Behavioral approaches help couples recognize these patterns and develop different ways of responding.

Integrative Behavioral Couple Therapy also emphasizes acceptance and understanding of differences, recognizing that not every disagreement or personality difference can or should be eliminated.


These approaches have established research support and remain legitimate options for couples seeking treatment.


They are worth understanding because effective couples therapy is not limited to the two methods most frequently discussed online.


Does Research Tell Us Which Marriage Counseling Method Is Best?


Research can tell us whether particular treatment approaches have demonstrated benefits, but identifying one universally superior method is much more difficult.


Studies of couples therapy vary in their populations, treatment duration, comparison groups, and definitions of improvement.


Couples also enter treatment with different concerns, relationship histories, mental health needs, and levels of motivation.


Evidence supporting one approach does not mean that every other approach is ineffective.


For example, reviews of behavioral and emotionally focused couples therapy have found improvements in relationship satisfaction. Research has also examined Gottman Method interventions and their effects on relationship functioning.


The responsible conclusion is that several established approaches can help couples improve their relationships.


What research cannot do is identify the best therapist or treatment plan for a particular couple without understanding their circumstances.


That requires clinical judgment, appropriate assessment, and an honest discussion of what the couple hopes to accomplish.


Why Therapist Specialization Matters


The name of the therapy method is only part of the decision.


Couples should also consider the experience, training, and qualifications of the person providing treatment.


A licensed mental health professional may be legally qualified to provide couples counseling without having advanced specialization in a particular couples-therapy approach.


But working with two partners simultaneously presents clinical challenges that differ from individual therapy.


A couples specialist must understand how two people's histories, emotions, expectations, and behaviors interact.


The therapist must be able to identify recurring relationship patterns, manage difficult conversations, recognize when conjoint treatment is inappropriate, and develop a treatment plan that accounts for both partners.


Experience with the particular concerns bringing a couple into therapy also matters.


A couple seeking help after betrayal, for example, may reasonably want someone with substantial experience addressing trust injuries and complicated relationship dynamics.


A couple considering separation may have different clinical needs from partners who want to improve communication in an otherwise stable marriage.


Neither situation should automatically receive the same treatment plan.


What Does It Mean to Be a Certified Gottman Therapist?


One distinction worth understanding is the difference between being trained in the Gottman Method and being a Certified Gottman Therapist.


The Gottman Institute offers progressive levels of professional training.


Clinicians can complete introductory and advanced training without necessarily completing the full certification process.


Becoming a Certified Gottman Therapist requires additional qualifications and a formal certification process involving consultation, demonstrated application of clinical interventions, and evaluation of the therapist's work.


Certification is not the same as a professional license. It is an additional designation demonstrating completion of specialized requirements within the Gottman Method.


That distinction does not mean a therapist without certification is necessarily ineffective.


There are skilled couples therapists practicing within different evidence-based approaches, and formal certification is only one factor in evaluating professional competence.


But for couples specifically seeking Gottman Method treatment, understanding the therapist's level of training can help clarify the experience and qualifications behind the services being offered.


Alexis Honeycutt, LMHC, has been a Certified Gottman Therapist since 2023 and has approximately 13 years of experience as a therapist as of November 2026.


Her practice focuses on marriage, relationships, communication, trust repair, and individualized couples treatment.


Treatment Approach and Session Structure Are Two Different Decisions


An important distinction often gets overlooked when couples begin researching therapy.


The type of therapy and the way therapy is scheduled are not the same thing.


The Gottman Method and Emotionally Focused Therapy are treatment approaches.


Weekly appointments and private couples intensives describe how therapeutic time is organized.


A couple can receive Gottman Method treatment during regularly scheduled appointments. A trained clinician can also use Gottman Method interventions in a concentrated, multi-hour intensive.


Likewise, emotionally focused approaches may be incorporated into different treatment schedules when clinically appropriate.


The treatment model helps determine how the therapist understands and addresses relationship problems.


The session structure determines how much uninterrupted time is available for that treatment.


These are related decisions, but they are not interchangeable.


A couple evaluating treatment should ask both what clinical approach the therapist uses and whether the proposed schedule makes sense for the concerns being addressed.


When Might a Private Couples Intensive Be Appropriate?


For some couples, a standard weekly appointment provides an appropriate opportunity to address concerns gradually and practice changes between sessions.


Other couples may benefit from concentrated clinical time.


An intensive typically begins with individualized assessment and treatment planning, followed by extended therapeutic conversations and interventions.


The longer sessions give the therapist and couple time to pursue significant issues without repeatedly stopping at the end of a conventional appointment.


This may be valuable when a couple is dealing with entrenched conflict, damaged trust, persistent communication difficulties, or relationship concerns that require substantial exploration.


Couples do not necessarily need to be in crisis to benefit from this structure.


Partners seeking greater emotional connection, more satisfying communication, or deeper relationship understanding may also be appropriate candidates.


However, an intensive is not automatically suitable for every relationship or clinical situation. The decision should follow appropriate professional assessment.


The essential distinction is that the clinical treatment approach and the intensity of the schedule can be considered together.


A Gottman-informed couples intensive is not a separate treatment school competing with the Gottman Method. It is one way an appropriately qualified therapist may organize and deliver individualized couples treatment.



Questions to Ask Before Choosing a Marriage Counselor


Rather than choosing a therapist solely because a website advertises a particular method, couples can benefit from asking several specific questions.


What experience does the therapist have working primarily with couples?


What approach do they use, and why do they consider it appropriate for the concerns being presented?


What training or certification have they completed?


Will treatment begin with an assessment of the relationship?


How does the therapist determine treatment goals and evaluate whether progress is occurring?


Are weekly appointments the only available structure, or are other clinically appropriate arrangements offered?


And what happens if the assessment reveals that a different type of care is needed?


Clear answers can reveal more about the treatment a couple will receive than an impressive list of therapeutic terminology.


Choosing the Right Approach for Your Marriage


The best type of marriage counseling is not necessarily the one with the most recognizable name or the most persuasive claims.


It is treatment delivered by a qualified professional who understands the relationship's needs, applies an appropriate clinical approach, and can explain why that approach makes sense.


The Gottman Method, Emotionally Focused Therapy, and established behavioral approaches offer different ways of understanding and addressing relationship difficulties.


Couples deserve to know those options exist.


They also deserve to understand that choosing a treatment model does not automatically determine whether therapy must take place once a week or over a more concentrated period.


For couples throughout Florida, including Orlando, Oviedo, Winter Park, Palm Beach, Naples, and South Florida, seeking specialized relationship care may involve looking beyond the nearest available counselor.


The important decision is finding a professional whose expertise and treatment approach are appropriate for the relationship, whether that care takes place through ongoing appointments or an individually arranged intensive.


Understanding the available approaches is a valuable starting point.


Understanding what your particular relationship needs is what makes the decision meaningful.


Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page